Too Many Books

 * To read this and get any use from it, you'll have to buy in to something resembling this - John was incapacitated in the family room, dragged to the basement (2 flights of stairs - there's a landing) and his phone had been taken up through the bulkhead door to the backyard, and that Jen's phone spoke to someone other than John on John's phone (likely Brian Albert) for 8 seconds from 12:28-44 to 12:28-53 after Karen drove away from 34 Fairview. And to be honest, if you don't think the basement was used, you're welcome to switch my references to the back yard to the four seasons room (back porch) or garage. For my purposes, Brian Albert is in the backyard with co-conspirators when a call from Jen's phone comes in - John's phone is "ringing." John's phone is in the backyard and is lying  still . Maybe it is sitting on the grill or on the blue tub that is shown in the Zillow pictures of 34 Fairview. Both are near the back gate. No steps are ...

Imagine, if you will, a world in which Julie Nagel did not go outside to talk to her brother. What if a different brunette went outside instead? At 12:27am. We've been told *cough* that there is a screen shot of text messages from Ryan Nagel saying "here" and "leaving."  What if those weren't the only texts?  RYAN NAGEL : here (12:23am) JULIE : don't need a ride after all (12:25) RYAN NAGEL, annoyed : really? JULIE : Bri's other friends bailed. Feel bad. JULIE : Prob just spend the spend the night. RYAN NAGEL : Cool RYAN NAGEL : Leaving (12:27am)  From the police reports, it seems that Ryan was mentioned to the Canton PD early on  (at the scene) as a potential neutral 3rd party eyewitness. But in his initial statement to Yuriy and Michael Proctor on February 7, 2022, he tells us some things that turn out to be patently false - he says he saw Karen initially to the left of the house if you're looking at it from the road, and then further up by ...

Whether or not you agree that John and Karen got to 34 Fairview at 12:21 (see previous) post - we're picking up from there.  Per Nick Guarino and Ian Whiffin: 12:21:10 – 12:24:22 80 steps 287 feet During time frame from above:     12:22:14 – 12:24:37 Ascending/ descending 3 “floors” (flights) So, there's a gap. John's phone is showing steps from 12:21-10 - 12:22:14 that are NOT up and down stairs.  This is the time frame, in the family room, that he was incapacitated. Puffed up chests, punch, dog, dog again, punch, thrust backward. Insert whoever's fist you'd like, but John went down and hit his head on the fireplace before 12:22:14.  Yes, the fight broke out, and John was down in about a minute - fights happen fast. (Regarding family rooms and fights, if you haven't followed Samantha Beningo and the "I Don't Belong Here" You Tube channel, I high...

I tend to bury the lead, so let me say this up front: I won't get to any of it in this post, but by 12:24:22am on January 29, 2022, John O'Keefe had arrived at 34 Fairview, gone into the house, been incapacitated, and had been dragged down the two short flights of stairs down to the basement, and up the stairs to and through the bulkhead door.  Yes. All of this happened by 12:24:22am. And here's how I started my research this week to figure it out: When I decided to look at timeline, I didn't think I'd spend all my free time in an entire DAY focusing on the short time frame of 12:11am - 12:21:09. I wanted to go "back to the start" (shoutout to Coldplay!) and figure out what the time discrepancy was really all about. I started with steps: Hyde (report) 12:11:09 - 12:21:09 170 steps 326 feet Guarino (testimony) 12:11:09 – 12:21:05 170 steps 326 feet Whiffin (report) ...

Edit: ideal to read this with the FOIA drive open to access each ring video referenced as you go. Other recommended research/ reading: The Commonwealth's Statement of the Case June 2022 pg 14, and Evan Brent's trial 2 testimony. I am now CERTAIN Karen broke her taillight pulling into John's garage when she arrived home from FV. Here's why: The first time we see it broken (to my eye!) is  in the FOIA Ring Doorbell cam - we see Karen backing out at 5:07am. As Boozey Beauty pointed out, the angle in which she's backing out is odd. The beginning of the FOIA footage shows the SUV backing out and if you move the banner showing the play/ pause buttons, I think you'll see it. Watch the first 3 seconds, if you haven't already. I watched in .25 speed and paused each second. FOIA file ID 1643450878000. The TL doesn’t look “right” as it passes the illuminated vertical frame of the garage door on the left of the screen. Look at shape, not color. It’s better on video, bu...